> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://www.growthsolutionskc.com/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# Disagreement Is Not Hatred
- URL: https://www.growthsolutionskc.com/disagreement-is-not-hatred/
- Published: 2026-11-03T14:00:00.000Z
- Updated: 2026-11-03T22:43:49.000Z
- Author: Matt Cucinotta
- Tags: Civic & Community, #America, #growthsolutionskc, #National Policy

### *Why defending the female category should not require courage, and why the rules that protect speech must work for everyone*

![audio-thumbnail](https://storage.ghost.io/c/42/b4/42b4b6b8-b1f2-4aa3-8c91-88f72e71a120/content/media/2026/11/Disagreement_Is_Not_Hatred_thumb.png)

Disagreement Is Not Hatred

0:00

/760.378617

1×

---

On July 28, two teenage girls sat courtside at Climate Pledge Arena in Seattle. They had stayed up the night before making signs. One read, “Thank you Sophie for speaking up for girls.”

They had come to see Indiana Fever guard Sophie Cunningham, whose comments to ESPN in support of keeping biological males out of women’s sports had made her the center of a national argument. According to the girls and the journalist accompanying them, one of the Seattle Storm’s co-owners approached, cursed at them, and called them insane. One of the girls left in tears. They put their signs away.

The next day, the Storm apologized. The WNBA fined the co-owner and suspended her from the team’s next five home games. Cunningham answered with a sentence worth more than most of the commentary that followed: “You can disagree and still be kind.”

That sentence is the subject of this article.

In August, [*Women’s Sports Were Built for Women* ](https://www.growthsolutionskc.com/womens-sports-were-built-for-women/)argued that sanctioned competition in the female category should be reserved for biological females. That position has not changed. This piece asks a different question, a civic one: can an American defend that position in public without being treated as a bigot? And can the people on the other side of it be treated with the same decency?

---

## **A Pattern, Not an Incident**

Seattle was not an isolated moment.

Days later in Minneapolis, Cunningham was booed on her first touch and throughout the game while critics and supporters gathered inside and outside the arena. Her comments set off three rallies and a debate that reached the White House. Her own response was simple: she wanted to get back to basketball.

Kendall Kotzmacher, a Minnesota softball player whose high school team lost a state championship game to a team with a transgender pitcher, says she has received hate texts and death threats since speaking publicly, including a threat to come to her college and kill her. Outside the Minneapolis rally, she says, a counter-protester told her she should have been aborted. She has lost friends. Her explanation for continuing is plain: **it is easy to be frightened back into silence.**

In Monroe, Michigan, a family that filed a Title IX complaint over a high school volleyball game says it was threatened with violence, called Nazis, and received a threat to blow up its home, serious enough that the FBI made contact.

In Washington State, two Skyview High School runners walked off a cross-country course in September rather than race a male-born athlete who had switched to the girls’ team midseason. In October, about a dozen Camas High School girls did the same. One father received a criminal trespass notice barring him from district property for a year. He says it followed his chanting “Keep boys out of girls sports” on the way to his car. The district says he drove through a taped-off area and nearly struck a security staff member, and that the notice concerned his conduct, not his views.

Many of these accounts come from the people who lived them, and not every detail has been tested. But the pattern is consistent enough to take seriously: Americans, many of them young women, who say the female category should be reserved for females are increasingly met not with argument but with contempt.

---

## **What Hatred Is, and What It Is Not**

![](https://storage.ghost.io/c/42/b4/42b4b6b8-b1f2-4aa3-8c91-88f72e71a120/content/images/2026/10/Hatred-versus-disagreement_-conduct-matters-10.png)

Words matter here, because one word has been doing most of the work.

Hatred is ill will toward a person: a desire to harm or demean, or to deny someone their dignity. Disagreement is a different judgment about what a rule should be. The first is aimed at someone. The second is aimed at a policy.

A sign thanking an athlete for speaking up for girls is not hatred. Neither is a wristband marked “XX,” a T-shirt reading “Save Girls’ Sports,” or a teenager deciding not to race. Each expresses a view that most Americans share. The Pew Research Center found that 73 percent of U.S. adults are uncomfortable with transgender athletes competing on teams that do not match their sex at birth.

Calling that view hatred does not refute it. It ends the conversation before it begins.

> ***Hatred is aimed at a person. Disagreement is aimed at a policy. Confusing the two does not settle the argument. It only silences one side of it.***

---

## **The Line Is Conduct, Not Viewpoint**

A federal appeals court recently drew this line with unusual clarity.

In September 2024, two fathers and a grandfather at a girls’ soccer game in Bow, New Hampshire, quietly put on pink wristbands marked “XX” at halftime to protest a transgender athlete’s participation on the opposing team. School officials, with a police officer present, ordered the wristbands removed and later issued no-trespass orders. The principal called the symbol hateful and anti-trans. The superintendent described the protest as intimidating, threatening, and harassing.

On August 26, 2026, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the First Circuit disagreed. It held that the families were likely to succeed on their claim of unconstitutional viewpoint discrimination. **Silent wristbands, the court found, fell short of substantial disruption or harassmen**t, and there was no evidence any player had even seen them. The case now returns to the district court and is not a final judgment. The principle, however, is plain: **officials may not punish a viewpoint simply because they find it offensive.**

That principle protects everyone. A school can and should stop threats, intimidation, harassment, and unsafe behavior, by anyone and about anything. What it may not do is decide which side of a public debate is permitted to speak.

![](https://storage.ghost.io/c/42/b4/42b4b6b8-b1f2-4aa3-8c91-88f72e71a120/content/images/2026/10/Conduct--not-viewpoint-3.png)

---

## **The Honest Ledger**

A standard that cuts only one way is not a standard.

Hostility in this debate does not run in one direction. In Monroe, the athletic director was placed on paid leave after expressing empathy for the transgender athlete on a podcast. An independent investigator later found the Title IX complaint unsubstantiated, and he was reinstated. In Camas, as national attention grew, some online activists posted the transgender student’s name and images, turning a minor into a symbol for adults who had never met her. Teammates on both sides said the situation was manageable until the rest of the country arrived.

Pew’s research has also found that Americans can hold more than one conviction at once. In its 2022 survey, majorities favored requiring athletes to compete on teams matching their sex at birth while also favoring protections for transgender people against discrimination in everyday life. Fairness and dignity are not rivals. Most of the public already holds them together. Much of the public conversation does not.

![](https://storage.ghost.io/c/42/b4/42b4b6b8-b1f2-4aa3-8c91-88f72e71a120/content/images/2026/10/The-honest-ledger_-fairness-and-dignity-5.png)

---

## **What the Contempt Costs**

The consequences extend well beyond any single arena.

**People stop speaking.** A broad majority of Americans share the concern Cunningham voiced, yet the people who say so publicly are often young athletes absorbing the backlash alone. When agreement is common but public expression is rare, intimidation fills the gap, and policy is shaped by whoever is loudest.

**Children pay the steepest price.** Teenagers on every side of this question, including girls who walked off a course and a girl left in tears courtside.

**Institutions retreat.** Administrators who fear controversy from both directions avoid writing clear rules, improvise under pressure, and then discipline whoever is easiest to discipline.

**The debate degrades.** A question that deserves careful reasoning about physiology, fairness, privacy, and opportunity is reduced to accusations of bigotry on one side and cruelty on the other.

---

## **What Can Be Done**

**Police conduct, not viewpoint.** Silent protest, respectful signs, shirts, and interviews are protected expression. Threats, harassment, doxxing, and unsafe behavior are not, and they should be disciplined consistently no matter which side commits them.

**Write the rules in advance and apply them symmetrically.** The WNBA’s response in Seattle, a public apology followed by a fine and suspension for an owner, shows that accountability is possible even at the top of an organization.

**Make removal from public property follow a process.** New Hampshire responded to the Bow case by enacting HB 1184, overriding a governor’s veto on August 19, 2026; HB 1184 formally became law on August 20 and was enacted as Chapter 339\. It establishes procedures and appeal rights for no-trespass orders on municipal and school property. Other states should ask whether a single administrator should be able to ban a parent for a year without a hearing.

**Never make a child the face of a cause.** No names, faces, or images of minors in the service of anyone’s argument, on either side, for any reason.

**Show up with conviction and with charity.** That means school board meetings, athletic events, and the ballot box. On November 3, voters in Washington and several other states will decide whether to reserve girls’ and women’s sports for females. GSKC’s position on that question has been stated plainly and has not changed. But how Americans conduct this debate will shape the next generation as surely as how they decide it.

---

## **True, Good, and Beautiful**

**The True** asks us to say what is so: biological sex matters in athletic competition, and defending a protected female category is a legitimate position held by most Americans, not a prelude to cruelty.

**The Good** asks us to treat every person in this debate, including female athletes, transgender students, parents, coaches, and administrators, as someone whose dignity does not depend on whether they agree with us.

**The Beautiful** asks for something rarer: an arena, and a public square, ordered enough that a teenager can hold a handmade sign without being cursed at, and a classmate can be disagreed with without being exposed.

**Women’s sports were built for women**. Defending them should not require courage. Until it no longer does, those who speak up deserve our support, and those who disagree deserve respect.

> ***You can disagree and still be kind. That is not a slogan. It is the minimum a self-governing people owes one another.***

![](https://storage.ghost.io/c/42/b4/42b4b6b8-b1f2-4aa3-8c91-88f72e71a120/content/images/2026/10/Kindness-at-Center-Court-7.png)

---

**— Matt Cucinotta | Growth Solutions KC | Inspire · Inform · Ignite**

Explore more strategic analysis and policy commentary at [growthsolutionskc.com](https://www.growthsolutionskc.com/).

---

**Sources and Notes**

1. ESPN, “Amid tension, Cunningham says she wants to ‘get back to basketball,’” 2026\. [View source](https://www.espn.com/wnba/story/%5F/id/49538591/amid-tension-cunningham-says-wants-get-back-basketball?ref=growthsolutionskc.com)
2. Associated Press via NBC Chicago, “Rallies surround WNBA game after Sophie Cunningham’s comments on transgender athletes,” Aug. 2, 2026\. [View source](https://www.nbcchicago.com/wnba/sophie-cunningham-comments-transgender-athletes-rally-minnesota-lynx-fever/3969515/?ref=growthsolutionskc.com)
3. FOX 13 Seattle, “Seattle Storm co-owner fined, suspended after spat with fans,” July 30, 2026\. [View source](https://www.fox13seattle.com/news/seattle-storm-owner-suspended-indiana-fever?ref=growthsolutionskc.com)
4. Indianapolis Business Journal, “Seattle Storm co-owner Celeste Keaton suspended by WNBA after incident with fans at Fever game,” 2026\. [View source](https://www.ibj.com/articles/seattle-storm-co-owner-celeste-keaton-suspended-by-wnba-after-incident-with-fans-at-fever-game?ref=growthsolutionskc.com)
5. Yahoo Sports, “Seattle Storm Co-Owner Suspended Over Fan Clash” (Cunningham statement), 2026\. [View source](https://sports.yahoo.com/articles/wnba-news-seattle-storm-co-183114073.html?ref=growthsolutionskc.com)
6. Fox News / OutKick, “NCAA softball player reveals alleged encounter with pro-trans counterprotesters at Sophie Cunningham rally,” Aug. 2026\. (Advocacy-aligned outlet; athlete’s account.) [View source](https://www.foxnews.com/outkick-sports/ncaa-softball-player-reveals-alleged-encounter-pro-trans-counterprotesters-sophie-cunningham-rally?ref=growthsolutionskc.com)
7. Fox News / OutKick, “Michigan teen speaks out about taking a stand for women’s sports,” 2026\. (Family’s account.) [View source](https://foxnews.com/outkick-sports/michigan-father-alleges-bomb-threat-home-daughter-spoke-up-facing-trans-athlete-without-knowing?ref=growthsolutionskc.com)
8. Michigan Advance, “Monroe AD on leave after expressing empathy for trans athlete amid parent’s Title IX complaint,” Dec. 19, 2025\. [View source](https://michiganadvance.com/2025/12/19/monroe-ad-on-leave-after-expressing-empathy-for-trans-athlete-amid-parents-title-ix-complaint/?ref=growthsolutionskc.com)
9. CBS News Detroit, “Monroe Public Schools reinstates athletic director after Title IX investigation concludes,” 2026\. [View source](https://www.cbsnews.com/detroit/news/monroe-public-schools-reinstates-athletic-director-title-ix-investigation/?ref=growthsolutionskc.com)
10. The Seattle Times via The Spokesman-Review, “Camas cross-country runners protest transgender teammate as tensions mount,” Oct. 15, 2026\. [View source](https://www.spokesman.com/stories/2026/oct/15/camas-cross-country-runners-protest-transgender-te/?ref=growthsolutionskc.com)
11. OPB, “Protest in Southwest Washington against trans runner on girls cross-country team goes viral,” Oct. 19, 2026\. [View source](https://opb.org/article/2026/10/19/camas-washington-transgender-high-school-sports?ref=growthsolutionskc.com)
12. LGBTQ Nation, “Teen runners say media circus over trans teammate ruined the season,” Oct. 2026\. (Advocacy-aligned outlet; teammates’ accounts.) [View source](https://www.lgbtqnation.com/2026/10/the-fun-wasnt-there-anymore-teen-runners-say-media-circus-over-trans-teammate-ruined-the-season/?ref=growthsolutionskc.com)
13. U.S. Court of Appeals for the First Circuit, *Fellers v. Kelley*, No. 25-1442, decided Aug. 26, 2026\. [View source](https://law.justia.com/cases/federal/appellate-courts/ca1/25-1442/25-1442-2026-08-26.html?ref=growthsolutionskc.com)
14. Pew Research Center, “Most Americans are uncomfortable with transgender athletes on sports teams that don’t match their birth sex,” Aug. 11, 2026 (survey fielded November 2025). [View source](https://www.pewresearch.org/short-reads/2026/08/11/most-americans-are-uncomfortable-with-transgender-athletes-on-sports-teams-that-dont-match-their-birth-sex/?ref=growthsolutionskc.com)
15. Pew Research Center, “Americans’ Complex Views on Gender Identity and Transgender Issues,” June 28, 2022\. [View Source.](https://www.pewresearch.org/social-trends/2022/06/28/americans-complex-views-on-gender-identity-and-transgender-issues/?ref=growthsolutionskc.com)
16. New Hampshire General Court, HB 1184 (2026), relative to the issuance of no-trespass orders on municipal or school district property; veto overridden Aug. 19, 2026\. [View source](https://fastdemocracy.com/bill/nh/2026/bills/NHB00014318/?report-bill-view=1&ref=growthsolutionskc.com)
17. Axios Seattle, “Washington voters weigh ban on trans girls in girls’ sports,” Oct. 21, 2026\. [View source](https://axios.com/local/seattle/2026/10/21/washington-i638-2026-election-k12-girls-school-sports-rules?ref=growthsolutionskc.com)
18. Growth Solutions KC, “Women’s Sports Were Built for Women,” Aug. 31, 2026\. [View source](https://www.growthsolutionskc.com/womens-sports-were-built-for-women/)